Nahmanides and the Big Bang
The Big Bang theory is believed to have been first proposed in the 20th century, but was actually proposed much earlier by biblical scholars, taken from information in the Old Testament.
The earliest existing reference is in a commentary on the book of Genesis written by Nahmanides (1194-1270) Of course, Nahmanides never referred to it as the ‘big bang’, but this is basically how he described the first moments of the universe. Here it is in Schroeder’s own words:
From Gerald Schroeder: “Genesis and the Big Bang”
“In the thirteenth century, Nahmanides quoted a commentary on Genesis written 600 years before him, noting that prior to the existence of the universe, time did not exist. This was learned from the wording of Genesis 1:5, “. . . and there was evening and there was morning, day one.” It is not stated “the first day.” For the use of first would have implied an already existing series of days or a continuum of time when in fact on this “day one” there had been no prior time to this one day…”
Nahmanides’s account of the first seconds of the universe reads like this:
“At the briefest instant following creation, all the matter of the universe was concentrated in a very small place, no larger than a grain of mustard. The matter at this time was so thin, so intangible, that it did not have real substance. It did have, however, a potential to gain substance and form and to become tangible matter. From the initial concentration of this intangible substance in its minute location, the substance expanded, expanding the universe as it did so.”
The Second Law of Thermodynamics states that Energy cannot be killed. Energy is permanent; the form in which Energy changes, but Energy continues forever. We are mostly composed of Energy. My parents, with whom I wasn’t a friend, are still existent, somewhere. Absence of tangible presence does not mean dead; their absence is only physical.
I was a very reluctant convert to Faith, which happened in my third year of college. Theologically, I was raised in Nothing. The last several years have challenged a lot of beliefs I adopted in churches. It isn’t church or religion that explains death very well. I have left a number of churches; the most recent leaving is a result of politics—not really a good reason for leaving, but if I’m honest that is the reason. I dealt with their politics for over a decade. During that time, politics did not mandate how I was supposed to think. That changed in 2017; when hypocrisy became official.
I am by nature, a recluse. I deal with ‘absence’ from church better than my wife; who has a social personality. I still need to work on how to make this work better for her.
I prefer the Second Law of Thermodynamics to church. I have ‘faith music’ playing all day.
“In a very real sense, we are all aliens on a strange planet. We spend most of our lives reaching out and trying to communicate. If during our whole lifetime, we could reach out and really communicate with just two people, we are indeed very fortunate.” Gene Roddenberry
My life experienced wonder and self-understanding on September 8, 1966, when I learned that I was a Vulcan that was stranded on Earth. That was a novel explanation of how my brain works. I have never done emotion well. I did not have pointy ears and green blood, but I did emotion-avoidance well. Probably a factor in not being a friend of my parents, and so many others…
But time just seemed to vanish
Right before my eyes
You may not understand it
Why we live with the sacrifice
But it’s worth every mile
To get to sing for a while
Truth is I’ve done it all for free
Always rhymes to be makin’
When you’re a dream chaser like me
From “Dream Catcher” by Willie Nelson
It is difficult to consider intangible ideas at this point in time. My email account receives more than 300 email messages each day; almost entirely about the recent elections.
I am 74, and I have a pension. I haven’t had an income for this entire year; and yet I persist with making illustrations for ‘free’. I believe it will prove to be a worthwhile ambition.
Creator does not have an agenda—at least in the way most humans use the term. Creator is by nature. Absence of tangible presence does not mean dead.

























